The media wants you to believe that the reopening of the Cornell sexual assault case by the local district attorney is a triumph of the legal system working as intended. Look closer. It is nothing of the sort. It is a damning indictment of a broken apparatus that only stirs into action when public outrage threatens institutional self-preservation.
When the allegations first surfaced involving members of the Chi Phi fraternity, the Tompkins County District Attorney initially took a pass, leaning entirely on an initial police review rather than conducting an independent investigation. Let us call that what it is: administrative cowardice. Prosecutors across upstate jurisdictions routinely outsource primary fact-finding to campus security units whose primary financial and operational directive is risk management, not law enforcement. Discover more on a related subject: this related article.
When universities act as police departments, judges, and juries, justice becomes an internal PR exercise. Cornell managed the fallout through internal Title IX hearings that doled out wrist-slaps—suspensions, probation, and mandatory reflection papers—while the accused men walked free from criminal exposure. Not a single arrest was made until a high-stakes civil lawsuit filed by the survivor forced the state’s hand, prompting Governor Kathy Hochul to step in and appoint the state attorney general as a special prosecutor.
This is the lazy consensus we must dismantle: the notion that campus disciplinary boards can effectively handle violent felonies. They cannot. They are bureaucratic entities designed to limit liability, shield endowments, and avoid bad press. When an institution investigates itself, concealment is a feature, not a bug. Additional analysis by The Washington Post delves into comparable views on the subject.
The legal standard required to trigger an actual criminal response should never depend on whether a victim can afford high-powered civil litigators to shame public officials into doing their baseline jobs. By admitting that his office relied entirely on campus police files without independent inquiry, the district attorney laid bare a systemic abdication of duty.
Stop praising the system for correcting its own catastrophic failure years too late. Demand a complete structural divorce between academic institutions and criminal investigations. Until local prosecutors stop treating campus crimes as internal administrative grievances, universities will remain safe harbors for predators wrapped in Greek letters.