History isn’t just written by the victors; it’s sanitized by them. When a violent insurrection overthrew a legitimately elected multiracial government in Wilmington, North Carolina, in 1898, the architects of the coup didn’t just seize power. They rewrote the filing cabinets of American memory. They called it a race riot for over a century, shifting the blame onto the very Black citizens whose homes were burned and whose lives were stolen.
Journalist and author Lauren Collins takes direct aim at this historical amnesia in her vital book, They Stole a City. Rather than treating the Wilmington massacre as an isolated blip in the Jim Crow era, Collins traces its shockwaves across generations by tracking four specific local families—both Black and white. She exposes how a violent template for white supremacy was normalized, hidden behind closed doors, and scrubbed from textbooks so effectively that generations grew up completely blind to the foundational fracture in American democracy. For a different view, read: this related article.
The Anatomy of an American Coup
To understand why the cover-up worked so well, you have to look at what actually happened on November 10, 1898. Wilmington was a thriving port city. It had a growing Black middle class, successful Black-owned businesses like the Daily Record newspaper, and a Fusionist political coalition of Republicans and Populists holding office.
White supremacists couldn't stomach it. Led by figures like former Congressman Alfred Moore Waddell, an armed mob of white men marched into the city, torched the Daily Record building, forced the elected mayor and aldermen to resign at gunpoint, and banished Black and white leaders alike. People were murdered. Thousands fled into the swamps or were permanently exiled. Related insight on the subject has been provided by The Guardian.
Yet, the perpetrators managed to flip the script immediately. They claimed they had merely restored order after a lawless Black uprising. This inversion of truth became the official local lore. State history books ignored the armed overthrow for decades, opting instead for a comforting myth about the natural restoration of good government.
Why the Cover Up Lasted So Long
Concealing a historical crime of this magnitude takes active, systemic effort. The conspiracy of silence in Wilmington survived because local power structures depended on it. If you admit that a city government was violently overthrown and a thriving Black community was structurally liquidated, you have to answer uncomfortable questions about property deeds, generational wealth, and stolen futures.
White families who benefited from the coup inherited homes, businesses, and political dominance that traces directly back to the vacant lots left behind in 1898. Meanwhile, Black families spent generations navigating the emotional and economic fallout of sudden dispossession. Collins explores this qualitative damage—asking what gets lost when a community is robbed not just of physical safety, but of its collective hope and generational continuity.
Statutes, street names, and monuments celebrated the white supremacists as heroes for decades. The official state report on the coup didn't even drop until 2006, more than a hundred years later. Even then, acknowledgment without systemic restitution left a gaping hole.
Facing the Ledger of the Past
Statistics alone cannot capture the horror of a stolen city. Numbers tell you how many people left, but they don't explain the psychological weight carried by descendants who grew up knowing the truth while the rest of the country looked away.
When you read through the personal lineages in Collins' work, you realize that history is never really behind us. It sits at the dinner table. It shapes who gets loans, who owns land, and whose ancestors are memorialized in bronze. Confronting these truths requires dismantling the sanitized narratives we tell ourselves about American exceptionalism. We have to stop treating white supremacist insurrections as southern anomalies and start recognizing them as blueprints for how democratic systems can be subverted from within.
Look closely at your own local history. Dig past the town plaques and the celebratory Founders Day parades. The stories we choose to forget usually hold the key to the problems we are trying to solve right now.
They Stole a City with Lauren Collins